I fell in love at sweet sixteen
Ain't ever felt a cut that deep
I blamed him and he blamed me
I cried so hard I couldn't breathe

So I swore off love for quite some time
Till a bad boy took me for a ride
And that went how you'd think it'd go
And I said, "I guess I'll die alone"

I got good at sleeping by myself
I got good at not needing no one else

But now I think it's happening again
You put a brand new kind of wind back in my sails
Took my heart off of the shelf
And you're not nothing like I've known
I'm already scared to let you go
Tonight, I'm laying in your arms
Praying that the third time's the charm

You're patient and you're twice as kind
And there's a book that says that's some good sign
You calm my crazy every time
You think I'm kind of crazy but you don't mind

Now I think it's happening again
You put a brand new kind of wind back in my sails
Took my heart off of the shelf
And you're not nothing like I've known
I'm already scared to let you go
Tonight, I'm laying in your arms
Praying that the third time's the charm

I could probably get back up
If this goes south and I lose your love
But I don't wanna know a world
Where you're not mine and I'm not your girl

Baby, I think it's happening again
You put a brand new kind of wind back in my sails
Took my heart off of the shelf
And you're not nothing like I've known
I'm already scared to let you go
Tonight, I'm laying in your arms
Praying that the third time's the charm