Dressed to the nines, perfect blue eyes
I looked around, not a red flag in sight
My daddy liked you, and that was a first
You promised him you'd be the guy I deserve

Ohh-oh-ohh, too good to be true
Ohh-oh-ohh, we were wrong about you

You weren't supposed to be just like the rest
You swore up and down that you loved me to death
Now we're in my driveway and I'm now your ex
'Cause I'm way too much and you need something less
Ohh-oh-ohh, why does this happen every time?
What's wrong with me? Am I that bad?
You felt like you had to take my broken heart and fix it
Just to turn around, turn around
And break it right back, break it right back

You knew my past and begged me to try
To love again, because it'd end different this time
But words are just words and you're just a guy
And I'm just the girl you looked at like a prize

You weren't supposed to be just like the rest
You swore up and down that you loved me to death
Now we're in my driveway and I'm now your ex
'Cause I'm way too much and you need something less
Ohh-oh-ohh, why does this happen every time?
What's wrong with me? Am I that bad?
You felt like you had to take my broken heart and fix it
Just to turn around, turn around
And break it right back

So go use your fancy big words at your fancy big job
Tell your friends how you're right and how I'm just so wrong
And how you do it all and I don't do enough
How you can't settle down with a girl that lives on a tour bus

You weren't supposed to be just like the rest
You swore up and down that you loved me to death
Now we're in my driveway and I'm now your ex
'Cause I'm way too much and you need something less
Ohh-oh-ohh, why does this happen every time?
What's wrong with me? Am I that bad?
You felt like you had to take my broken heart and fix it
Just to turn around, turn around
And break it right back