(Everything happens for a reason sometimes
Even the shitty things)
I didn't answer your call in September
But it's fair to say you won the ghosting competition
The stubborn hundred fold you really can't get rid of
I think by now I get it
Your mother said that you were looking hard for truth
An ancient god that you got as a shitty tattoo
Scoffed at all your thoughts and then I thought them too
Guess we're both laughing about what we thought we knew
Cause now you ruin my dates playing the songs you showed me
At every Nashville bar, keeping me from moving on
Cause I can cry on the drive but now I'm rolling my eyes
Because the irony's not lost
I think you'd like me
Even better now, you might have been right babe
Wish I could tell you how we disagreed on reincarnation
Till I couldn't stop you from sticking around
Amethyst, rule of three
Wish I knew what you believe these days
You said in August you met some new friends then
Sent me the list of principles of hermeticism
Pendant on your neck, you went and pierced your lip
And I really thought I'd get to see you grow out of it
You told me that you loved me on the phone
Now you're the vulnerable moment that I have with someone new when we get close
I think you'd like me
Even better now, you might have been right babe
Wish I could tell you how we disagreed on reincarnation
Till I couldn't stop you from sticking around
Amethyst, rule of three
Wish I knew what you believe these days
I know you might have moved on
I'm just one of all the people taking you where they go
It's all hypothetical
I feel your reactions
Constantly imagine what you'd say if you could answer your phone
I used to scream into the sky
Cause there's no fucking reason why
You're fossilized inside my mind with everything I'll never know
But that's a hypothetical
But I think you'd like me
Even better now, you might have been right babe
Wish I could tell you how we disagreed on reincarnation
Till I couldn't stop you from sticking around
Amethyst, rule of three
Wish I knew what you believe these days
Wish we didn't both agree everything is in the right place