You know I wanna make up
But you call at all the wrong times
I'm going crazy read my mind
So read in between the lines
It's hard to fake it
I should just say it

You know I'm tired of the same old thing
I crave something new
I know it's wrong to wish for something
That'll never be true
I hold it sacred
I shouldn't waste it

Always gotta be somebody else you’re fucking seeing
Always gotta be stuck in these lies I keep believing
Red T-shirt blue eyes dark hair
Slipping into a nightmare
Always gotta be stuck in it
Always gotta be stuck lovin'

You know I see the reasons that you drive
To San Francisco
You reassure me saying I'm the one
That you'll miss though
I know it isn't true
But I stick to loving you

I wanna break out and I wanna tell you
What you did wrong
But we'll just break up and I’ll put your bullshit
Into a song
And you can listen
From a distance

Always gotta be somebody else you’re fucking seeing
Always gotta be stuck in these lies I keep believing
Red T-shirt blue eyes dark hair
Slipping into a nightmare
Always gotta be stuck in it
Always gotta be stuck lovin'

I know it's been a while but don't say I'm too late
Call off your date
Say you can't stay
Come home to broken dinner plates
I know we're not the same but opposites attract
We're so mismatched
I'm so attached
You're everything I never had

Muddy white sneakers
Big picket fences
I'll be the good girl
You'll be my exes
I'll kiss you goodnight
I'll shut the door tight
I'll do it all right
Not like that time

Always gotta be somebody else you’re fucking seeing
Always gotta be stuck in these lies I keep believing
Red T shirt blue eyes dark hair
Slipping into a nightmare
Always gotta be stuck in it
Always gotta be stuck lovin'