I met you, thought you were cute
Gave you my number, you seemed happy
Thought you might have been the one
But no, you lied to me
Why'd you only tell me now?
Why didn't you tell me then?
You should have just told me
You should have just told me
Why'd you have to lead me on?
Why'd you have to lead me on?
I would never take you from him
But why did you get my hopes up?
Thought I'd finally found someone
Guess not, 'cause I'm still all alone
Alone
Why'd you only tell me now?
Why didn't you tell me then?
You should have just told me
You should have just told me
Why'd you have to lead me on?
Why'd you have to lead me on?
Well, at least nothing happened
Wouldn't want to live with that guilt
Told me before it was too late
I'm glad I held my ground
Still you could have just told me no
Could have told me you had someone
You could have not led me on
'Cause now I'm hopeless once again
You should have just told me
You should have just told me
Why'd you have to lead me on?
Why'd you have to lead me on?
Why'd you have to lead me on?
Why'd you have to lead me on?
You should have just told me
You should have just told me
Why'd you have to lead me on?
Why'd you have to lead me on?