Windows down in your Mercedes-Benz
That night felt so innocent
We danced in your kitchen light
Somehow you made me feel like I was the only girl in sight
It escalated in your bedroom
You said "It's fine, I promise we don't have to"
For the first time I didn't feel bad
This can't be real, it's perfect, no guy is like that

But then I woke up to an unfamiliar face
My clothes on the floor, your back turned away from me
And I got home feeling empty and weak
'Cause I must've left a piece of me in your sheets
And you haven't spoken to me since
You said that you'd text
Why'd I feel like you just wanted to have sex

It's funny 'cause you weren't my plan
But that'll change when we kiss to "Piano Man"
Was everything you said just a game?
I'll never forget the way I felt that day

When I woke up to an unfamiliar face
My clothes on the floor, your back turned away from me
And I got home feeling empty and weak
'Cause I must've left a piece of me in your sheets
And you haven't spoken to me since
And you said that you'd text
But I feel like you just wanted to have sex