[Verse]
Who's that guy babe I don't know
He walks like a shadow slow
He smiles that way you adore
But he’s never been here before

[Verse 2]
He’s got your eyes he’s got your grin
He moves like he’s been here within
But tell me babe who is he
I don't know him can't you see

[Chorus]
Who's that guy babe tell me now
Don't leave me here wondering how
He got so close in our space
With that unknown familiar face

[Verse 3]
I see him watching me watch you
His gaze is sharp his eyes are blue
But you just laugh and play along
Like he's been here all along

[Bridge]
Something ain't right can't you feel
There's a mystery that's real
In the shadows in the night
Who’s this guy who caught your sight

[Chorus]
Who's that guy babe tell me now
Don't leave me here wondering how
He got so close in our space
With that unknown familiar face