When you told me on that night
You had a really good time
I hoped that meant there would be more

As I talked you always smiled
We were there for quite a while
As we left they closed and locked the door

When I saw you on the next day
You asked if you could have a word
You said that you were sorry
But it was only fair that I heard

You told me you were leaving
Going to Denver in the spring
You said you really loved me
But it wasn't meant to be
Now I'll always remember
The way it felt so right
As I held you in September
When the magic was just for the night

You said it was just one date
But I swear it felt like fate
When I left you left me wanting more

I heard it said, 'too good to be true'
It comes to mind when I think of you
I guess we never can be sure

When I saw you on the next day
You said you had something to say
You said that you were sorry
But there was no other way