Met you back when I was thirteen
Never dreamed you’d hurt me like you did
Held my hand and said you loved me
And I was all you’d ever need, babe
Called me up years later, said you hate her
And you wanted me back
Have a tendency to fall for boys who play me
And lie like that
You and I, the magic we had
You and I, all in my head
If I still loved you like I used to
I would be dying just to live
I would be crying on the kitchen floor
If I still loved you like I did
Nine years, you’ve been gone now
I’m moving on now
Just like you were never there
But there’s moments I remember
Everything you’ve ever done, oh
Left me lying in the dark there
Broke my heart there
At that party on New Year’s Eve
Have a tendency to fall for boys who play me
And pretend they wanted me
You and I, the magic we had
You and I, all in my head
If I still loved you like I used to
I would be dying just to live
I would be crying on the kitchen floor
If I still loved you like I did
So, you were my first love
But you were my worst love
Just you and me, all we used to be
So you were my first love
But you were my worst love
You took away what it meant to me
If I still loved you like I used to
I would be dying just to live
I would be crying on the kitchen floor
If I still loved you like I did
If I still loved you like I used to
I would be dying just to live
I would be crying on the kitchen floor
If I still loved you like I did
If I still loved you like I used to
I would be dying just to live
I would be crying on the kitchen floor
If I still loved you like I did