We don't know what it was but we had it
We don't where it went but we lost it
And it may never come back again but I sure wish it would
We don't know what it was but it sure was good

The first time I laid eyes on you I saw it
Shining in your eyes was bright as day
And when I held you in my arms I felt it
Oh, but like a fool I let it slip away

We don't know what it was but we had it
We don't where it went but we lost it
Well, it may never come back again but I sure wish it would
We don't know what it was but it sure was good

First time that we kissed I could taste it
Sweet upon my lips like a song
The moment we made love I knew we'd found it
One day I woke up and it was gone

We don't know what it was but we had it
We don't where it went but we lost it
And it may never come back again I sure wish it would
We don't know what it was but it sure was good

If you had one more chance would you take it?
And would you stand beside me from now on?
The second time around could we make it
And would you be there with me, hold it on

We don't know what it was but we had it
We don't where it went but we lost it
And it may never come back again but I sure wish it would
We don't know what it was but it sure was good
No, we don't know what it was but it sure was good