My best friend didn't like you when we first met
Was hard to not let that get into my head
My dad didn't trust you 'til a year in, ah
That's not how I imagined it going
Sometimes I get so mad that I could hate you
And I question if I'm really meant to stay with you
But then I hate the thought of life without you, ah

That's not how I imagined me knowing
Now it's me and my bad habits
Layin' next to you, yeah
You and all your baggage

When I
Thought it'd be rainbows and butterflies
Thought it'd be shameless sex every night
Thought it'd be a sure thing
Wouldn't feel like I was making a choice
But it's just a broken girl, loving a broken boy

You talk about mistakes you made with exes
And all you're trying to say is you regret it
But something inside me is kinda jealous, ah
That's not how I imagined it feeling

God bless the broken road that led me straight to an imperfect person
Feels like the world's been lyin' to me my whole life, 'cause I

Thought it'd be rainbows and butterflies
Thought it'd be shameless sex every night
Thought it'd be a sure thing
Wouldn't feel like I was making a choice
But it's just a broken girl, loving a broken boy

It's just a broken girl, loving a broken boy
It's just a broken girl
Yeah, it's me and my impatience
Layin' next to you and all your unrealistic expectations

Rainbows and butterflies
Shameless sex every night
Thought it'd be a sure thing but it feels like
I'm making a choice
Yeah, I'm just a broken girl, loving a broken boy