Nothing like a memory to open up a broken heart
It's been years but I look at you now and we're torn apart
Nothing like a face to take you back to the time
When it was you and I against the world, just you and I

And I wish it hadn't happened to us, you fell in love with that girl
And I wish it hadn't happened to us, you fell in love with that girl
And I wish it wasn't true when all you cared about was the girl

Nothing like a lover to set you up for a fall
Leave you feeling ready to die, like you lost it all
Nothing like you and I, in that place and time
And it's so hard letting go 'cause you're still on my mind

And I wish it hadn't happened then, but you fell in love with that girl
Yeah, I wish it never happened to us, you fell in love with that girl
And I wish it wasn't true when all you cared about was the girl