Called me on my birthday
I thought you'd be on your way, oh
Candles burned down to the cake
Still not seeing your face

I can't spend this one wish on you
Ooh, woo-ooh

I can't forgive you
No matter how hard I try
I can't forget you

If promises are gonna break
Why promise in the first place?
Running low on lemonade
Crying over paper plates

I can't spend this one wish on you
Ooh, woo-ooh

I can't forgive you
No matter how hard I try
I wanna love you

Tried to go out of my way
But couldn't find the words to say
Left a message with your mama
Oh, she gave me drama
I hope that your one wish does come true
I miss you

I can't spend this one wish on you
Ooh, woo-ooh

I can't forgive you
No matter how hard I try
I can't forget you
And I can't hate you
No matter how hard I try
I just pretend to