And when I tell you that I loved you most of all
I wonder if it's true
Seems every time my heart was headed for a fall
It wonders what to do
I remember, how you would look at me
And see what no one else could see

Memory fails as memory pales
Did our love exist?
Or am I rewriting history?

And there are reasons why I know we did not last
And I know they're real
And, no, I don't deny the pain that's in our past
But I feel what I feel
Am I crazy even imagining we can turn out differently

Memory fails as memory pales
Are you the love I missed
Or am I rewriting history?

I may be fooling myself, I may be fooling you
God knows we were foolish then
But when I see you like this
I miss, I miss you
I miss you all over again
I miss you all over again

And when I tell you that I loved you most of all
I wonder can it be
I have no way to know the things that you recall
When you think of me
Say you miss me, or say you never do
But once and finally set me free

Memory fails as memory pales
I know I should resist
But we could try rewriting history

Memory fails as memory pales
I know I should resist
But could we try rewriting history

We could try rewriting history