I remember when we laughed so hard
We couldn't breathe
Sipping on milkshakes
Making memories with ease
But now it feels
Like all I do is cry
Tears rolling down my cheeks
Wondering why

I'm crying over spilled milkshake
Reminiscing about
All the love we used to make
Every drop, every word
Every little mistake
Now all that's left are tears
I can't shake

Late-night talks
And dancing in the rain
Our love was a melody
Never a strain
But now the music
Has faded away
Leaving me with tears
That won't go astray

I'm crying over
Spilled milkshake
Reminiscing about
All the love we used to make
Every drop, every word
Every little mistake
Now all that's left
Are tears I can't shake

The memories linger
Like a bittersweet dream
But all I see now
Are tears in the stream
I wish I could turn back time
Make it right
But for now
All I can do is cry through the night

I'm crying over spilled milkshake
Reminiscing about
All the love we used to make
Every drop, every word
Every little mistake
Now all that's left
Are tears I can't shake

I'll hold onto the memories
Even if they make me ache
But for now, I'll keep crying
Over this spilled milkshake